Monday, November 4, 2013

Amy's Lentil Soup Copycat Recipe

Print Friendly and PDF

Lentil Soup.  It's not not ugly...

But guys, remember Beauty and the Beast?  Looks aren't everything!!!  Behind that plain-looking mask is all of this deliciousness...

Side Note:  The Hubby refers to an Onion, Celery, and Carrot mixture as 'The Trifecta,' which stems from confusion over the cooking term, 'The Holy Trinity,' (which is Onion, Celery, and Bell Pepper), and this makes me laugh every single time.  Because he says it every single time.  It's funny.    

This soup is one of my new favourites, and here is why...

I'm so predictable with my lunches at work.  Four days out of five I will bring soup, whether it's homemade or out of a can.  It's so predictable and so boring, but it works for me.  My co-worker / friend Tyler says "Classic Megan" every single day when he sees me and my soup.  And if I'm eating a canned soup, nine times out of ten it will be Amy's Organic Lentil Soup.  The problem here is that Amy's Soups are expensive when you purchase them one by one, usually about $4 per can.  Now friends, at Costco you can get an 8-pack for about $12.25, which reduces it to about $1.50 each.  And what's even better is that one time (my other co-worker / friend Ashley will totally be rolling her eyes at this story because she's heard it about five times), I even picked up the 8-pack on sale for $8 (quick math = $1 per can!).  Ever since then I have been chasing the dragon, but the deal has never reappeared.  

Don't judge a book by its cover!
And, something else not so great has also happened (and this is where my story gets really vapid and you can please feel free to skip right to the recipe).  The 8-pack used to be four cans of lentil and four cans of 25%-reduced sodium vegetable lentil.  Fine.  OK.  Then they decided to change to four cans of lentil and four cans of 50%-reduced sodium vegetable lentil.  OK, not my first choice, but 'beggers can't be choosers' and all that.  It's healthier for me, at least I still like half of the cans, and with the other half I can add a couple of shakes of salt if necessary.  Lentil soup needs salt, it just does.  Then, Costco went ahead and changed their Amy's soup program to four cans of 50%-reduced sodium lentil soup and four cans of 50%-reduced sodium vegetable lentil soup.  Who made this decision, and did they think that I wouldn't notice?  Now I end up adding way too much extra salt to my soup to try to replicate the taste of the full-sodium version, which makes me feel unhealthy because it is.  Paying $4 per can for the regular-sodium version at the grocery store is out of the question, and I would rather just make my own version anyways.  So, here we are.  Here we are.

And that's when I decided to play around with a basic lentil soup recipe that I had until I could get it to taste just like the regular Amy's canned Organic Lentil Soup that I love.  And, I think I got it.  I think this is really it.  I think this is as close as it can get without actually being Amy (and without using any organic ingredients whatsoever like the Ame-ster herself would have).  This soup tastes like the real deal.  I still love Amy's soup, but it's nice to be able to make it at home too.    

High in protein.  High in fibre.  High in nutrition.  High in flavour.  Here is my rendition of the best...let me know what you think!

For another Lentil Soup recipe, check out this Beef Lentil Soup from Souper Sunday #16. 

For a printer-friendly version of any recipe, simply click 'Print' below the title of any blog post.  Voila - a clean recipe without my ramblings or any pictures!

Souper Sunday #18: Lentil Soup (Amy's Lentil Soup Copycat Recipe)

Serves: 4 - 6

  • 2 cups dried green lentils, rinsed
  • 4 cups chicken broth
  • 2 cups water
  • 1 bay leaf
  • 1 sprig fresh thyme, leaves only (about 1 tablespoon)
  • 1 teaspoon olive oil
  • 1 onion, diced
  • 2 stalks celery, diced
  • 2 carrots, diced
  • 2 cloves garlic, finely diced
  • 1 1/2 teaspoons kosher salt
  • 1 1/2 teaspoons balsamic vinegar
  • 1 potato, peeled and cut into 1-inch cubes

In a large pot, combine lentils, broth, water, bay leaf, and thyme over medium-high heat.  Bring to a boil, then reduce heat to simmer, cover, and cook for 20 minutes.  Meanwhile, heat your olive oil in a large pan over medium heat.  Add onion, celery, carrots, and garlic, and cook for 10 minutes or until vegetables are tender.  Add the salt and balsamic vinegar and cook for 30 more seconds.  Spoon the vegetables into the pot of cooked lentils.  Add the cubed potato to the pot.  Turn the heat up to high, bring the soup to a boil, then reduce heat to a simmer.  Cover pot and cook for 60 minutes.  Remove soup from heat.  If your soup is too thick at this point, add a cup of hot water or broth to thin it out, then heat for a minute or two longer.  Using an immersion blender, give the soup quick a quick blend or two, leaving lots of chunks and being sure not to puree the soup completely.  Serve hot.

Recipe Inspired By:  Ben & Birdy
What Was Cooking on Playing With My Food One Year Ago:  Man Pleasin' Chili


  1. This looks amazing! I have been searching high and low for Amy's Lentil Vegetable Soup recipe. Would you consider trying to replicate that one? Thank you!!

    1. Thank you so much for reaching out! Did you try the lentil soup recipe? I think it's really good and very similar to the real thing. I haven't had an opportunity to make the lentil vegetable soup, but will add it to my 'to-do' list. Thanks for the suggestion!

      Have a great weekend,

  2. I love this soup! I, too, enjoy Amy's lentil soup, so it was nice to find this copycat recipe. I only made one adjustment: there was a lack of fresh thyme at the store, so I used ground thyme. In my opinion, 1 teaspoon is plenty. I guarantee this soup is going to be made again in the near future!

    1. Thank you for reminding me about this recipe by commenting! I am going to make this again this week. I think I may even like this recipe better than the real thing by Amy herself! :)

    2. I think when you use the dry herb you need to use less than the fresh because its stronger. ☺

  3. I just found this recipe, and will try it soon! I also used to get them at Costco and notice the different ones now lol. Thought I'd Google a copycat recipe and here it is! Thanks!

  4. This is exactly like Amy's version thank you for the great recipe! X

  5. I haven't tried this version yet but the recipe seems the closest to the ingredients on the can. My son I are chronically ill and on an alkaline diet. We cannot have vinegar of any kind. We are allergic to it anyway. The ingredients on the less sodium Amy's organic lentil soup can include,water, lentils, celery, carrots, onions, potatoes, olive oil, salt and bay leaves. Why do all the copies have some sort of vinegar? Also, thank you for having a recipe without tomatoes. We cannot have tomatoes either and most of the copy recipes I've found have them. I just want to be able to give my sick son something he enjoys that tastes good, fits into his medical diet and doesn't cost me $2.89 for a can. He's losing too much weight so I'm desperately searching for things he enjoys that I can make affordable at home that the other kids will like as well. Everyone loves Amy's organic lentil soup but with a family of six that gets expensive. How will not including the vinegar affect the flavor and the results?

    1. The regular and light sodium Amy's lentil don't have vinegar. Only the lentil veg has it. I'll be leaving it out as I can't have it either.

  6. This recipe tastes exactly like Amy's, Amy's is the only recipe that tastes exactly like my mom's when I was a kid! I have had to skip the vinegar once and it didn't make much of a difference, at least I thought so.

  7. Just made this tonight. It was SO delicious and tasted just like the Amy's soup that I love. Thanks for the great recipe!

  8. You landed it!! Thank you! This recipe tastes just like Amy's Lentil Soup. Delicious and easy to make without the expensive price tag!! Awesome.

  9. I've made this numerous times and we love it! I'm looking for one similar to Amy's vegetable lentil soup now. Any ideas?

  10. Can this be made in an instant pot? How would I convert it?


Hi everyone! I would love to hear from you, so please leave your comments here. To comment without a Google ID, select 'Name/URL,' or 'Anonymous' from the drop-down menu above. Thanks for reading and commenting!


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...